In the era of work-from-home, it is rare of a need to access your home network from outside of your home. In the rarest occasion when we need something from your digital home, from accessing files in your NAS to viewing security camera footage, while being away, it is very inconvenient and less secure to get access from a public internet hotspot.
There are plenty of cloud-based P2P solutions for specific use cases and products, ranging from Synology’s QuickConnect that allows you to access your Synology NAS anytime, anywhere, from any device and browser, to security cameras’ remote access feature. However, cloud-based solutions are vendor-specific, requiring different setups and apps for different use cases; and it is as secure and the vendors’ security posture, which is usually not very high. The P2P communication may not be encrypted end-to-end using proper algorithm, making it possible for attackers on your public WiFi hotspot, on the internet, or at the compromised vendor cloud, to eavesdrop your access. In addition, a trip to the cloud is almost not the shortest path, especially you are not far away from home.
Remote-access VPN comes into play. We are all familiar with it; when we work from home, we use it all day long to connect to the corporate network. A remote-access VPN gives employees access to secure connection from anywhere on the internet to a remote private network and they can access resources on the private network as if they were directly plugged into it. Remote-access VPN establishes virtual tunnels between a client and a server. The laptop your employer provides already have remove-access VPN configured: it could be part of the operating system, or dedicated application like Cisco AnyConnect. They are the VPN client. A network access server is either the dedicated server or applications running on or behind your internet gateway router that VPN tunnels are established to. The client-server architecture allows a variety of protocols, either standard/open-source or proprietary, to provide the same functionality.
Given that I have an EdgeRouter and I do not want to run dedicated VPN access server or applications for some rare use cases, I went for what EdgeOS supports. EdgeOS supports PPTP, L2TP, and OpenVPN servers. So first, we need to decide on a protocol.
PPTP stands for point-to-point tunneling protocol, and it has been in common operating systems for a long time (since Windows 95 for example). PPTP has known vulnerabilities.
L2TP stands for Layer 2 Tunnel Protocol. It is a VPN protocol that does not offer any encryptions, so it is usually implemented with IPSec encryption. The combo is usually referred as I2TP/IPSec VPN. IPSec is secure, however L2TP adds overhead and complexity. First, the packet is encapsulated by adding PPP, L2TP, and UDP headers (L2TP runs on UDP port 500), then encrypted in IPSec and ESP header added, and the outer IP header is attached at last.
OpenVPN uses the OpenSSL encryption library extensively, as well as the TLS protocol, and contains many security and control features. It uses a custom security protocol that utilizes SSL/TLS for key exchange. It is capable of traversing network address translators (NATs) and firewalls. Being relatively new, OpenVPN is usually not built into operating systems. It can run in the userspace so it can be installed as an app in both desktop and mobile operating systems, increasing its versatility. It supports pre-shared keys, username/password, and certificates.
Therefore, OpenVPN is the best option.
Server Configuration in EdgeOS
Configuring OpenVPN on EdgeRouter requires the use of CLI and the documentation is not very clear. It requires user to have reasonable understanding of what’s going on with certificate generation and signing. I attempt to add gotchas along the way.
- Make sure that the date/time is set correctly on the EdgeRouter.
show date Mon Jan 21 12:13:07 UTC 2019
- Change to root user:
- Generate a Diffie-Hellman (DH) key file and place it in the
openssl dhparam -out /config/auth/dh.pem -2 2048
Generating a Diffie-Hellman (DH) key file can take a long time. It took more than an hour for me.
- Go to
/usr/lib/ssl/misc. Certificate and key generation should be run from this directory using the helper script.
- Generate a root certificate using helper script:
Make sure you remember the passphrase. The passphrase will be used to sign the server and client certificates.
- Copy the newly created certificate + key to the
cp demoCA/cacert.pem /config/auth cp demoCA/private/cakey.pem /config/auth
Keep the root certificate in
/usr/lib/ssl/miscfor later use.
- Generate, sign, and move the server certificate.
./CA.pl -newreq ./CA.pl -sign mv newcert.pem /config/auth/server.pem mv newkey.pem /config/auth/server.key
- Remove password from server key file.
openssl rsa -in /config/auth/server.key -out /config/auth/server-no-pass.key mv /config/auth/server-no-pass.key /config/auth/server.key
If this step is skipped, the clients will need to enter the password when connecting.
- Generate certificates for clients. The combination of country, state, location, organization, common name, and email address should be specified and must be unique among the server and all clients, otherwise cert signing will fail. Set the name of your client in the variable
./CA.pl -newreq ./CA.pl -sign CLIENT=client mv newcert.pem /config/auth/$CLIENT.pem mv newkey.pem /config/auth/$CLIENT.key openssl rsa -in /config/auth/$CLIENT.key -out /config/auth/$CLIENT-no-pass.key mv /config/auth/$CLIENT-no-pass.key /config/auth/$CLIENT.key chmod 644 /config/auth/$CLIENT.key
Repeat for all your clients.
- Once done, verify the contents of the
/config/authdirectory. It should include DH key file, root certificate, server certificate, and all client certificates and keys. Exit root user.
- Now, add the router’s open VPN configuration.
- Add a firewall rule to allow the OpenVPN traffic to the
set firewall name WAN_LOCAL rule 30 action accept set firewall name WAN_LOCAL rule 30 description openvpn set firewall name WAN_LOCAL rule 30 destination port 1194 set firewall name WAN_LOCAL rule 30 protocol udp
- Configure the OpenVPN virtual tunnel interface
set interfaces openvpn vtun0 mode server
Create a server and client subnet using
172.16.1.0/24but it can be set to anything that suits your network.
set interfaces openvpn vtun0 server subnet 172.16.1.0/24
Then install a route
192.168.1.0/24on the client, thus making this network available over the OpenVPN tunnel. You should specify the correct subnet range you want to access remotely.
set interfaces openvpn vtun0 server push-route 192.168.1.0/24
Next, set up the DNS server over the VPN tunnel. I hope you use Pi-Hole!
set interfaces openvpn vtun0 server name-server 192.168.1.1
- Link the server certificate/keys and DH key to the virtual tunnel interface.
set interfaces openvpn vtun0 tls ca-cert-file /config/auth/cacert.pem set interfaces openvpn vtun0 tls cert-file /config/auth/server.pem set interfaces openvpn vtun0 tls key-file /config/auth/server.key set interfaces openvpn vtun0 tls dh-file /config/auth/dh.pem
- Commit the changes and save the configuration.
commit ; save
- If you changed certificates, or created certificates for new clients, you need reload certificates. Restart the openVPN interface as root by
reset openvpn interface vtun0
Client requires the certificates and server information, in the form of address/domain name and port (1194). The certificates can be transferred from EdgeRouter using
scp username@<ip-address>:/config/auth/cacert.pem ~/Desktop/config
scp username@<ip-address>:/config/auth/client.pem ~/Desktop/config
scp username@<ip-address>:/config/auth/client.key ~/Desktop/config
With DDNS, we can specify a constant domain name without worrying about changing dynamic IPs assigned by the ISP.
Add the following information to the
client.ovpn configuration file:
remote <server> 1194
To send all traffic through the VPN connection, append the
er.ovpn configuration file with the following line.
The OpenVPN protocol is not one that is built into the Apple iOS operating system, thus a client app is required. OpenVPN Connect is the preferred client app. To load the client configuration, or “profile” into the app, we need to combine certs and keys with configuration into one file and load the file into OpenVPN Connect.
First, comment out the lines in the
ovpn file specifying the relative paths to the server, client certs and keys:
Then, add the content of these files to the end of the
[--- CONTENTS OF cacert.pem GOES HERE ---]
[--- CONTENTS OF client.pem GOES HERE ---]
[--- CONTENTS OF client.key GOES HERE ---]
The content of the
pem files should be certificate, not certificate request. If you see certificate request in these files, they are not signed properly. The content of the
key file should be RSA private key.
Then, upload this file to iCloud drive and download it using the
Files app, or AirDrop to your phone. Share the file with OpenVPN. It should prompt you to import the profile. Try not to email it to yourself, that’s less secure.